So, what am I talking about? Well, not that long ago I mentioned that I have a poetry.com account. Part of what I liked about it is people had to give feedback. I mean, you have to review two, to post anything.
Except, now people aren't really giving real reviews. At least not true reviews. People seem ot be writing up a small blurb making standard commentary about word choice and imagery then copying it and pasting it. And, of course, all this praise is not alone,they also leave a link in the review back to their own work which they ask you to reveiw in exchange for their "helpful" review.
I get that people want more reviews but this seems to negate the purpose of the two to post priniciple. If you aren't going to leave a real review, then you are wasting other's time. In order to get the poem posted I did two real reviews of other poems, so just copying and pasting nonsense reviews doesn't help anyone. In fact, it hurts me because once you've received reviews, your poem is taken out of the queue that of need to be reviewed poems. So, it may hurt any chance of my poem getting any real reviews.
It is also about as helpful as if they put "its a poem" as the comment, because of if it isn't real feedback I don't have anyway of gaging what I need to work on versus what I'm good at.
It is a harmful and pointless form of self-promotion. The peole who enjoy doing reviews would have reviewed them anyway, and those who don't aren't going to do it just because they see the link. And I am certainly not going to go out of my way to review their work when they couldn't be bothered to review mine when they were supposed to.
It is just frustrating. It is like someone who has never been in your house showing up on your door step and saying, "I love that it has walls and floors, you should come to my house and tell me about how much you like the artwork and themes I have chosen for each of the rooms and tell me what you think they say about the rest of house, as well as how they relate to me as a person."
I mean, it is like a restaurant owner on Yelp commenting on another restaurant with "I like that it has food." And then expecting that person to come to their restaurant and giving them a positive thought out review.
I use the term that I made because they seem the type that will start like this but soon won't care about the reviews at all. They will just want people to give them five stars. In fact, I saw a 5f5 comment on someone's poem not that long ago. (If you don't know, it means five for five. So, they rated five starts and want the person they rated to return the favor.) But that isn't an honest opinion or an honest reflection on the quality of the poem.
It almost damages the poem because even if the poem was 5 star worthy, the fact that stars were bought taints any potential praise that could be given to the poem.
I probably won't use this website much anymore. Not that I use it all that often anyway. I write sonnets and almost epics more often than anything else, and they are not really appreciated on this site. Though, I haven't tried an almost epic. But, I figured since they tend to be long I would only be asking for fake reviews because they tend to be on the long side they would only test people's patience.
I feel I've gotten a little more babble-y than usual. So, I'm going to end it for now. It might be awhile befofre I post again. Lots of things are due in the next few weeks, so I will scarcely have the free time to blog.